The popularity of the foreign exchange market has surged in recent years, largely because of the advantages it offers traders compared to stocks. There are fewer legal restrictions on forex trading, allowing you to compete with professional traders.
You don’t have to be a professional to trade successfully in the forex market. The information available is straightforward and understandable even to beginners.
The competition is less than in the stock market. There are many fewer companies in the forex market than in the stock market, meaning that it’s less crowded and less difficult to find a promising opportunity.
The spreads are typically lower in the forex market than in the stock market, meaning that you’ll earn a higher percentage of your investment when you trade.
disadvantages of forex trading
Although there are many advantages to forex trading, it isn’t right for every investor. Here are several disadvantages of forex trading compared to stocks.
Different holidays affect trading hours
The exchange-set open and close times vary from day to day, which can make it difficult to establish a consistent trading routine. Stocks usually trade from 9:30 a.m. until 4 p.m. Eastern time, but holidays can change those times. For example, the May 2021 stockop edia holidays calendar shows that the New York stock exchange is closed on six days during that month, including one full week.
Unlike the stock market, the forex market is open around the clock. The timings may be uncomfortable for those who like to start their trading days at 9 a.m. or 3 p.m.
High risk of failure
Although anyone can open a forex trading account, that doesn’t mean that everyone will be successful. The stocks with the highest chance of failure, according to stockopedia, are small-cap and high-volatility plays. meaning that the risk is high even for those with deep pockets and a firm understanding of market dynamics.
You can avoid this by finding a reliable forex broker to play against instead of competing directly against traders who have been in the business for years.
Compared to stocks, there is a higher risk of liquidity problems in the forex market, meaning that it may be difficult enings are scheduled for 8:30 a.m. Eastern time on Mondays. However, on Memorial Day, stocks will trade from 9:30 a.m. until 11:00 a.m.
The difference in opening times alone can eliminate many potential entry points into a stock, severely limiting your time to react to news that affects the company. Differing closing times can have an equally negative effect. The fluidity of the forex market makes it easier to take advantage of news releases affecting a foreign currency.
Stocks are considered extremely sensitive to timing because of the regulation surrounding them. For example, the SEC imposes restrictions on day trading of stocks. Although day trading is highly regulated, the same can’t be said for the forex market. There are almost no restrictions on who can trade and for how long.
The low barrier to entry is a double-edged sword. It makes it easy for anyone to start trading, but it also means there’s little to prevent inexperienced traders from flooding the market and causing massive fluctuations.
It also means that credit isn’t a factor in gaining access to the market. Credit-restricted investors won’t have any trouble getting in, and providers even offer forex trading via cell phone to customers who might otherwise be denied access to the stock market.
Less regulation also means fewer enforcement mechanisms in place should a broker start acting illegally. It’s the responsibility of traders to do their own research and only trade with reputable brokers.
Less restrictive rules about lucidity mean that players have more opportunity to play with the timing of their trades. Manipulating the timing of a trade to maximize profits or minimize losses is a concept called curve fitting, and it’s strongly discouraged because it undermines a model’s predictive ability.
Regulation, restriction, and transparency help prevent curve fitting, which is another reason stocks are considered more stringent than the forex market.
disadvantages of forex trading over stocks
Lack of regulation and enforcement also means there’s no way to ensure the fairness of the market. Fairness is a major part of investing in the stock market because regulators act as a deterrent against unfair practices like insider trading or price-setting manipulation.
The transparency of stock quotes gives traders accurate prices to use in their calculations. Although brokers must submit real-time quotations to the National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotation System, or NASDAQ, some forex websites don’t submit exact prices. inaccuracies in quote accuracy can adversely affect the models traders use to trade forex.
Lastly, stocks usually have fixed contracts, whereas the forex market has both fixed and expiry contracts. A fixed contract allows a trader to know exactly how long they’ll be in a position, which can help prevent some psychological problems like panic selling.
The upsides and downsides of trading stocks compared to trading the forex market give new investors a clear idea of what to expect when deciding which investment vehicle to pursue. Stocks offer long-term growth potential and regulated trading environments for those who do their homework. The forex market offers relatively low entry barriers and on-demand trading opportunities, albeit in an unregistered and lightly regulated environment.
The upsides and downsides of each platform can help new investors make smart investment decisions that suit their long-term goals.
For tips on how to get started as an investor, check out our beginner’s guide to investing. For advanced investor information, see our guide to advanced investing concepts.
For easy-to-understand definitions of investment terms and jargon — including Bear Market, Buy & Hold, Float, Fundamentals, Naked Shorts, P/E Ratio, PEAK, Put Options, Short Selling, Toxic Debt — visit our Finance Glossary.
Our Free Weekly Newsletter: Get free weekly updates of investing tips and tricks to grow your money — and fun! — faster.
Learn more about the upsides and downsides of trading stocks compared to trading the forex market and how each platform suits different investing goals.
Beginner Investor Tips | Advanced Investing Concepts | Finance Glossary | Free Weekly Newsletter
DISCLAIMER: This website or its content or both may change after this publication date without such change being specifically updated on this page. For current and up-to-date information about this site, please check its URL. Please review our complete Terms of Service for information regarding our services, rules for using this website, and disclaimers for this website.
This website is published by Stash, a private company. This website and any information provided through it do not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any securities or investments, nor should it be relied upon in connection with any such offer or solicitation. This website is not directed at residents of the State of Michigan or Indiana, and is not intended to comply with the requirements of Title 9, Chapter 5, Section 15 of the Securities Act of 1933; Section 5 under the Investor Protection Act of 1970; or the rules, regulations, and forms promulgated thereunder.
Accordingly, this website is not intended to be available to residents of the State of Michigan or Indiana, and participation in any securities offerings or transactions discussed herein shall only occur in qualified electors resident in Michigan or Indiana upon receipt of qualified written consent from Stash. Various state laws or state regulatory bodies may require qualification as, for example, an Indiana dealer or Michigan agent in order to participate in certain offerings disclosed on this website. Any information on this website is subject to change without notice, and Stash reserves the right to modify, add or remove any information or materials on this website at any time and without notice.